Beyond the gold-plated narrative: how to tackle construction costs
Construction of the Manawatu Bridge in Foxton, Horowhenua, with a crane beyond the bridge deck

By Dr Richard Templer, Chief Executive, Engineering New Zealand Te Ao Rangahau

It’s timely that New Zealanders are having an important conversation about infrastructure costs.

Whether it’s transport, water, energy or resilience projects, taxpayers rightly want confidence that every one of their dollars is being spent wisely. But if we’re serious about bringing costs down, we need to move beyond the simplistic narrative that engineers and consultants are driving up costs through so-called ‘gold plated’ solutions.

Infrastructure costs are shaped by decisions made throughout the entire system – from scoping, planning and procurement through to design, construction, and long-term asset management. Focusing on only one part of that system risks missing the real opportunities for greater efficiency and effectiveness.

One of the most positive developments in recent years has been growing recognition across the political spectrum that Aotearoa New Zealand needs a more stable and predictable infrastructure pipeline.

World-class infrastructure is built over decades, not election cycles; so greater political consensus gives engineers, agencies, councils and industry the confidence to plan, invest in capability, and develop the workforce needed to deliver projects efficiently.

Encouragingly, recent public debate has demonstrated meaningful common ground across the political spectrum on the need for long-term infrastructure planning. That consensus creates the conditions for innovation, productivity gains and stronger market competition.

When projects are delayed, cancelled or reprioritised, costs increase, skills are lost, confidence falls, and firms become less willing or able to invest in workforce capability. We are seeing the consequences of that uncertainty today as New Zealand continues to face a long-term engineering skills shortage.

It’s also important to recognise that decisions that influence total project cost are made well before detailed design work begins.

Major projects can become more expensive for many reasons, including changing objectives, scope adjustments, procurement settings, consenting challenges and risk allocation decisions. By the time these factors become apparent, they can appear as increases in design or construction costs, and be incorrectly dismissed as over-engineered.

Recently renewed discussions surrounding a second Auckland harbour crossing are a timely example that illustrates the complexity of infrastructure decision-making. Cost matters, but so does resilience, future capacity, network performance and long-term economic growth. These are value judgements as much as engineering judgements – that distinction matters.

Engineers undoubtedly play a role and have a responsibility to deliver efficient and practical solutions. But they also have a responsibility to ensure that infrastructure is safe, durable and fit for purpose over the long term. The key question should never be how cheaply an asset can be built, but rather how much value it will deliver over its entire life. That is how infrastructure decisions should be assessed.

Chasing lower up-front cost may come with a political or social sugar hit, but will almost inevitably result in higher costs downstream through increased maintenance, reduced performance, shorter asset life or expensive future upgrades. By contrast, investing appropriately at the outset can deliver better outcomes for communities and lower costs over time. The same principle applies to resilience.

Severe recent weather events across New Zealand have demonstrated that resilience is not a luxury. Infrastructure that can withstand future shocks helps to avoid much larger economic and social costs in the future. Cost efficiency should never be framed as a trade-off against resilience, safety or quality.

Finally, it’s also crucial for decision-makers and the public to understand that infrastructure investment isn’t only about building new assets. Better maintenance, renewals planning and asset management will futureproof investment alongside new capital projects.

There is no single cause of high infrastructure costs, and there is no single solution.

If we want better value from infrastructure investment, it needs to be a whole-of-system approach: long-term planning certainty, clear project objectives, smarter procurement, effective asset management, resilient design, and a strong engineering and construction workforce.

If we focus on those fundamentals, we can move beyond the simplistic gold-plated debate and concentrate on what really matters: delivering infrastructure that serves New Zealand well – now and for generations to come.

About the author

Dr Richard Templer is the Chief Executive of Engineering New Zealand Te Ao Rangahau, and previously the Chief Executive of Manawatu District Council.

Image: Construction of the Manawatu Bridge in Foxton, Horowhenua

Related Articles

Building Nations 2026

Smarter, Faster, Better. Around 1000 infrastructure leaders gathered in Ōtautahi, Christchurch, in August for Infrastructure New Zealand’s Building...

read more

How we buy

By Julien Leys, CEO, Building Industry Federation of New Zealand The hidden tax on every infrastructure project. In mid July, Aotearoa New Zealand’s...

read more